| Regulation of Investigatory Powers Bill - Amendments to be debated in the House of Lords (with hyperlinks from government Pt.III amendments to consolidated bill text by FIPR - please notify part3@fipr.org of any errors) Here you can browse the Third Marshalled List of Amendments to the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Bill to be moved in Committee in the House of Lords. |
| The amendments have been marshalled in accordance with the instruction of 6th June 2000, as follows-- | |||
| Clauses 25 to 46 Schedule 1 Clauses 47 to 57 Schedule 2 |
Clauses 58 to 73 Schedules 3 and 4 Clause 74 |
| [Amendments marked * are new or have been altered] | |||
No. |
|||
| Clause 25 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 99A | Page 27, line 11, leave out ("For the purposes of this Part surveillance is directed") and insert ("Subject to subsection (5A), surveillance is directed for the purposes of this Part") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 100 | Page 27, line 11, leave out ("but not intrusive") | ||
| 101 | Page 27, line 13, at
end insert--
|
||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE VISCOUNT ASTOR |
|||
| 102 | Page 27, line 15, leave out from ("person") to ("; and") in line 16 | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 102A | Page 27, line 21, leave out ("and (5)") and insert ("to (5A)") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 103 | Page 27, line 22, leave out from ("that") to end of line 27 and insert ("interferes with any person's privacy in circumstances where that person has a reasonable expectation of privacy") | ||
| 104 | Page 27, line 24, leave out ("residential premises") and insert ("premises or location where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 105 | Page 27, line 24, after ("vehicle") insert ("owned or occupied by anyone subject to surveillance") | ||
| 106 | Page 27, line 25, leave out paragraph (b) | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 107 | Page 27, line 27, at
end insert-- ("( ) Surveillance may be intrusive for the purposes of this Part irrespective of whether permission is obtained from a person able to give permission in respect of relevant premises to the conduct taking place on or in relation to those premises.") |
||
| 108 | Page 27, line 33, leave out paragraph (b) | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 109 | Page 27, line 35, leave out subsection (5) | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 110 | Page 27, line 43, at
end insert-- ("(5A) For the purposes of this Part surveillance which-- |
||
|
1949 c. 54. | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 111 | Page 28, line 14, leave out ("(b) or (c)") and insert ("(b), (c) or (d)") | ||
| 112 | Page 28, line 19, at
end insert ("; or
|
||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY |
|||
| 112A | Page 28, line 19, at
end insert ("; or
|
||
| Clause 26 |
|||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE VISCOUNT ASTOR |
|||
| 113 | Page 29, line 4, leave out subsection (3) | ||
| Clause 27 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 114 | Page 29, line 32, leave out paragraph (g) | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 115 | Page 29, line 41, at
end insert-- ("(5) The Secretary of State shall not make an order under subsection (3)(g) unless a draft of the order has been laid before Parliament and approved by a resolution of each House.") |
||
| Clause 28 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 116 | Page 29, line 45, at end insert ("other than in relation to a source whose conduct falls within section 25(7)(d)") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY |
|||
| 116A | Page 30, line 2, leave out ("believes") and insert ("is satisfied") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 117 | Page 30, line 21, leave out paragraph (g) | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 118 | Page 31, line 8, at
end insert-- ("(5A) The Secretary of State shall not make an order under subsection (3)(g) unless a draft of the order has been laid before Parliament and approved by a resolution of each House.") |
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 119 | Page 31, line 21, at
end insert-- ("( ) An authorisation for the conduct and use of a covert human intelligence source whose conduct falls within section 25(7)(d) shall be governed by the same procedures as apply to the authorisation of conduct for the carrying out of intrusive surveillance.") |
||
| Clause 29 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 120 | Page 31, line 43,
leave out subsection (4) and insert-- ("(4) A public authority is a relevant public authority for the purposes of this section--
|
||
| 121 | Page 32, line 18, leave out from ("authority") to second ("by") in line 19 and insert ("added to Schedule (Relevant public authorities) by an order made under subsection (4A)") | ||
| Clause 30 |
|||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY |
|||
| 121A | Page 33, line 3, leave out ("believes") and insert ("is satisfied") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 122 | Page 33, line 10, leave out paragraph (a) | ||
| 123 | Page 33, line 12, leave out paragraph (c) | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 123A | Page 33, line 32, at end insert-- | ||
|
1967 c. 77. | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 124 | Page 33, line 46, at
end insert-- ("(7) No authorisation shall take effect until such time (if any) as--
|
||
| Clause 31 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 124A | Page 34, line 36, leave out ("or of the City of London police force") and insert (", of the City of London police force or of a police force maintained under or by virtue of section 1 of the Police (Scotland) Act 1967") | 1967 c. 77. | |
| Clause 32 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 124B | Page 36, line 7, at end insert-- | ||
|
1967 c. 77. | ||
| 124C | Page 36, line 45, at end insert ("or section 5(4) of the Police (Scotland) Act 1967") | 1967 c. 77. | |
| Clause 33 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 125 | Page 37, line 28, at
end insert ("; and
|
||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 126 | Page 37, line 32, leave out subsection (6) | ||
| Clause 34 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 127 | Page 38, line 16, at
end insert ("; or
|
||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY |
|||
| 127ZA | Page 38, line 25, leave out ("believes") and insert ("is satisfied") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 127A | Page 39, line 28, at end insert ("or | ||
|
1967 c. 77. | ||
| Clause 35 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 128 | Page 40, line 1, leave out ("may") and insert ("shall") | ||
| 129 | Page 40, line 14, leave out ("may") and insert ("shall") | ||
| 130 | Page 40, line 18, leave out ("may") and insert ("shall") | ||
| 131 | Page 40, line 29, leave out ("may") and insert ("shall") | ||
| Clause 39 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 132 | Page 42, line 26, at end insert ("(other than in relation to law enforcement functions under section 1(4) of the Security Service Act 1989, as amended by section 1 of the Security Service Act 1996)") | ||
| Clause 41 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 133 | Page 44, line 25, leave out ("twelve") and insert ("three") | ||
| 134 | Page 44, line 37, leave out from ("for") to ("unless") in line 38 and insert ("any conduct falling within this Part") | ||
| Clause 42 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 135 | Page 46, line 10, leave out ("six") and insert ("three") | ||
| 136 | Page 46, line 12, leave out ("six") and insert ("three") | ||
| Clause 43 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 136A | Page 47, line 22, at end insert ("or | ||
|
1967 c. 77. | ||
| After Clause 43 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 136B | Insert the following new Clause-- | ||
(" .--(1) No
person shall grant or renew an authorisation under this Part for the
carrying out of any conduct if it appears to him--
|
|||
| Clause 45 | |||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 137 | Page 48, line 5, leave out ("(5)") and insert ("(5A)") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 138 | Page 48, line 39, leave out subsection (4) | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 138A | Page 49, line 6, leave out subsection (7) | ||
| Clause 46 |
|||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 139 | Page 49, line 35, leave out (", or is likely to do so") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 139WA* | Page 49, line 38, leave out (", or is likely to do so") | ||
| 139XA* | Page 49, line 42, leave out (", or is likely to do so") | ||
| 139YA* | Page 49, line 45, leave out (", or is likely to do so") | ||
| 139ZA* | Page 50, line 3, leave out from ("excise") to end of line 5 | ||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 139A | Page 50, line 5, at end
insert-- ("( ) If any person with the appropriate permission under Schedule 1 believes on reasonable grounds--
|
||
| 139B | Page 50, line 7, after ("believes") insert ("that the protected information cannot reasonably be obtained by him by means other than the giving of a notice under this section and if that person believes") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 139C | Page 50, line 10, leave out ("the imposition of a requirement to disclose the key") and insert ("a requirement to provide the information") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 139D* | Page 50, line 10, leave out ("requirement to disclose the key") and insert ("disclosure requirement in respect of the protected information") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 140 | Page 50, line 10, leave out second ("the") and insert ("such a") | ||
| 141 | Page 50, line 12, leave out sub-paragraph (ii) | ||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 141A | Page 50, line 17, leave out paragraph (d) | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 141B* | Page 50, line 17, leave out from ("that") to ("without") in line 18 and insert ("it is not reasonably practicable for the person with the appropriate permission to obtain possession of the protected information in an intelligible form") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 142 | Page 50, line 17, leave out first ("the") and insert ("such a") | ||
| 143 | Page 50, line 17, leave out ("key cannot reasonably be obtained") and insert ("protected information cannot reasonably be accessed or put into intelligible form") | ||
| 144 | Page 50, line 21, leave out first ("the") and insert ("such a") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 144A* | Page 50, line 21, leave out ("require the disclosure of the key") and insert ("impose a disclosure requirement in respect of the protected information") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 144B | Page 50, line 21, leave out ("the disclosure of the key") and insert ("him to provide the information in an intelligible form") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 144C | Page 50, line 21, leave out third ("the") and insert ("some such") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 144D* | Page 50, line 22, leave out ("requirement to disclose a key") and insert ("disclosure requirement in respect of any protected information") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 144E | Page 50, line 22, leave out ("to disclose a key") and insert ("under this section or section (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 144F* | Page 50, line 27, leave out ("requiring the disclosure of any key") and insert ("imposing a disclosure requirement in respect of any protected information") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 144G | Page 50, line 27, leave out ("requiring the disclosure of any key") and insert ("or section (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 145 | Page 50, line 28, leave out ("not in writing)") and insert ("given by electronic means)") | ||
| 146 | Page 50, line 29, at end insert ("and received") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 146A | Page 50, line 29, at
end insert--
|
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 147 | Page 50, line 31, leave out ("(2)(b)(i) or (ii)") and insert ("(2)(b)") | ||
| 148 | Page 50, line 31, leave out ("(2)(b)(i) or (ii)") and insert ("(2)(b)(ii) or (3)") | ||
| 149 | Page 50, line 33, at end insert ("and must identify the person who gave the appropriate permission, and the paragraph of Schedule 1 under which it was given") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 149XA* | Page 50, line 33, at
end insert--
|
||
| 149YA* | Page 50, line 34, leave out paragraph (e) | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 149ZA | Page 50, line 36, at
end insert--
|
||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 149A | Page 50, line 37, leave out ("the time by") and insert ("a period, not exceeding 40 days, within") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 150 | Page 50, line 37, at end insert (", such time being reasonable having regard to the technical difficulties of performing the disclosure") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 150ZA* | Page 50, line 38, leave
out paragraph (g) and insert--
|
||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 150A | Page 50, line 39, after
("notice;") insert--
|
||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 150B* | Page 50, line 40, after ("(a)") insert ("and subsections (4A) and (4B)") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 151 | Page 50, line 41, leave out ("the person giving it thinks fit") and insert ("may be specified by a code of practice issued under section 63") | ||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 151A | Page 50, line 41, leave out ("the person giving it thinks fit") and insert ("is appropriate for the purposes of the notice") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 152 | Page 50, line 41, at
end insert ("and
|
||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 152A* | Page 50, line 41, at
end insert-- ("(4A) Where it appears to a person with the appropriate permission--
(4B) Where it appears to a person with the appropriate permission--
(4C) Subsections (4A) and (4B) shall not apply to the extent that there are special circumstances of the case that mean that the purposes for which the notice is given would be defeated, in whole or in part, if the notice were given to the person to whom it would otherwise be required to be given by those subsections.") |
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 153 | Page 50, line 41, at
end insert-- ("( ) Where a person who has given a notice under this section is satisfied--
|
||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 153A | Page 50, line 42, leave out ("this section") and insert ("section (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 153B* | Page 50, line 42, leave out ("disclosure of a key") and insert ("making of any disclosure") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 154 | Page 50, line 46, at
end insert-- ("and such persons may not, without authorisation under this or another enactment, disclose the key to any other person or use the key to read any information other than that described pursuant to subsection (4)(b)") |
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 155 | Page 50, line 46, at
end insert-- ("but the provisions of the notice shall not specify or otherwise identify a person for the purpose of paragraph (b) unless he is of the class of persons who could have given the notice") |
||
| 156 | Page 50, line 46, at
end insert-- ("( ) A notice shall not be considered necessary on the ground falling within subsection (3)(c) unless the information protected by the key which is sought to be disclosed is information relating to the acts or intentions of persons outside the British Islands.") |
||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 156A | Page 51, line 1, leave out ("this section") and insert ("section (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 157 | Page 51, leave out
lines 2 to 5 and insert ("where--
|
||
| 158 | Page 51, line 5 at end
insert ("--
|
||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 158A* | Page 51, line 5, at end
insert-- ("( ) In this section "senior officer", in relation to a body corporate, means a director, manager, secretary or other similar officer of the body corporate; and for this purpose "director", in relation to a body corporate whose affairs are managed by its members, means a member of the body corporate.") |
||
| After Clause 46 | |||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 158B* | Insert the following new Clause-- | ||
(".--(1) Subject to
the following provisions of this section, the effect of a section 46
notice imposing a disclosure requirement in respect of any protected
information on a person who is in possession at a relevant time of both
the protected information and a means of obtaining access to the
information and of putting it into an intelligible form is that he--
(4) Subsections (5) to (7) apply where a person ("the person given notice")--
(6) Where--
(7) Subject to subsections (5) and (6), the person given notice shall not be taken to have complied with the disclosure requirement by the disclosure of a key unless he has disclosed every key to the protected information that is in his possession at a relevant time. (8) Where, in a case in which a disclosure requirement in respect of any protected information is imposed on any person by a section 46 notice--
(9) This subsection applies to any information that would facilitate the obtaining or discovery of the key or the putting of the protected information into an intelligible form. (10) In this section "relevant time", in relation to a disclosure requirement imposed by a section 46 notice, means the time of the giving of the notice or any subsequent time before the time by which the requirement falls to be complied with.") |
Effect of notice imposing disclosure requirement. | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 158C | Insert the following new Clause-- | ||
(" . If
the Secretary of State or judge giving permission under Schedule 1 is
satisfied that--
|
Permission for notice requiring key disclosure. | ||
| Before Schedule 1 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 159 | Insert the following new Schedule-- | ||
| ("SCHEDULE | |||
| RELEVANT PUBLIC AUTHORITIES > | |||
| PART I | |||
| RELEVANT AUTHORITIES FOR THE PURPOSES OF SS. 27 AND 28 | |||
| Police forces etc. | |||
| 1. Any police
force. 2. The National Criminal Intelligence Service. 3. The National Crime Squad. 4. The Serious Fraud Office. |
|||
| The intelligence services | |||
| 5. Any of the intelligence services. | |||
| The armed forces | |||
| 6. Any of Her Majesty's forces. | |||
| The revenue departments | |||
| 7. The
Commissioners of Customs and Excise. 8. The Commissioners of Inland Revenue. |
|||
| Government departments | |||
| 9. The
Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. 10. The Ministry of Defence. 11. The Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions. 12. The Department of Health. 13. The Home Office. 14. The Department of Social Security. 15. The Department of Trade and Industry. |
|||
| The National Assembly for Wales | |||
| 16. The National Assembly for Wales. | |||
| Local authorities | |||
| 17. Any local authority (within the meaning of section 1 of the Local Government Act 1999). | 1999 c. 27. | ||
| Other bodies | |||
| 18. The
Environment Agency. 19. The Financial Services Authority. 20. The Food Standards Agency. 21. The Intervention Board for Agricultural Produce. 22. The Personal Investment Authority. 23. The Post Office. |
|||
| PART II | |||
| RELEVANT AUTHORITIES FOR THE PURPOSES ONLY OF S. 27 | |||
| The Health and Safety Executive | |||
| 24. The Health and Safety Executive. | |||
| NHS bodies in England and Wales | |||
| 25. A Health Authority established under section 8 of the National Health Service Act 1977. | 1977 c. 49. | ||
| 26. A Special Health Authority established under section 11 of the National Health Service Act 1977. | 1977 c. 49. | ||
| 27. A National Health Service trust established under section 5 of the National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990. | 1990 c. 19. | ||
| The Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain | |||
| 28. The Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain.") | |||
| Schedule 1 |
|||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 159A | Page 83, line 1, leave out paragraph 4 | ||
| 159B | Page 83, line 19, leave out ("without any grant of permission") and insert ("if written permission has been granted by the Secretary of State or") | ||
| Clause 47 |
|||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 159C* | Page 51, line 7, leave
out from beginning to ("unless") in line 21 and insert-- ("(1) A section 46 notice imposing a disclosure requirement in respect of any protected information shall not contain a statement for the purposes of section (Effect of notice imposing disclosure requirement)(3)(c)") |
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 160 | Page 51, line 12, leave out second ("the") and insert ("a") | ||
| 161 | Page 51, line 16, leave out first ("the") and insert ("that") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 161A* | Page 51, line 23, leave out ("a section 46") and insert ("the") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 162 | Page 51, line 29, leave out ("the key itself") and insert ("an actual key") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 162A | Page 51, line 38, at
end insert-- ("and if he does give such a direction, he shall immediately inform the Interception of Communications Commissioner") |
||
| BY THE EARL OF LIVERPOOL THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 163 | Page 51, line 38, at
end insert-- ("( ) In considering whether the giving of a direction is proportionate for the purposes of subsection (4)(b), regard must be given to the extent and nature of information other than the protected information in question which may be protected by the same key.") |
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 164 | Page 51, line 38, at
end insert-- ("( ) The person required to disclose a key shall be taken for the purposes of this Part to have complied with that requirement if, by the time by which he is required to disclose it to any person, he has disclosed any key which is capable of accessing the protected information or (as the case may be) putting it into an intelligible form.") |
||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 164A | Leave out Clause 47 and insert the following new Clause-- | ||
(" .--(1) A
person shall not require the disclosure of a key unless he believes on
reasonable grounds--
|
Disclosure of key. | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| The above-named Lords give notice of their intention to oppose the Question that Clause 47 stand part of the Bill. | |||
| Clause 48 |
|||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 164AA | Page 51, line 42, after ("46") insert ("or (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| Clause 49 | |||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 164AB* | Page 52, line 2, leave out from ("person") to end of line 6 and insert ("to whom a section 46 notice has been given is guilty of an offence if he fails, in accordance with the notice, to make the disclosure required by virtue of the giving of the notice.") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 164B | Page 52, line 3, at beginning insert ("with intent to impede access to protected information or the putting of that information into an intelligible form,") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE VISCOUNT ASTOR |
|||
| 164C | Page 52, line 3, after ("he") insert ("intentionally") | ||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 164D | Page 52, line 3, leave out ("any") and insert ("a valid") | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 164E | Page 52, line 3, after ("46") insert ("or (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 165 | Page 52, line 6, leave out ("or has had") | ||
| 166 | Page 52, line 6, at end insert ("or who is reasonably able to obtain such possession") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 167 | Page 52, line 6, at end
insert (", or had possession of the key--
|
||
| 167A | Page 52, line 6, at end
insert-- ("( ) A person is guilty of an offence if--
|
||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 167B* | Page 52, line 7, leave out from ("section,") to end of line 8 and insert ("if it is shown that that person was in possession of a key to any protected information at any time before the time of the giving of the section 46 notice, that person shall be taken for the purposes of those proceedings to have continued to be in possession of that key at all subsequent times, unless it is shown--") | ||
| 167C* | Page 52, line 10, leave
out from ("it") to end of line 14 and insert-- ("( ) For the purposes of this section a person shall be taken to have shown that he was not in possession of a key to protected information at a particular time if--
|
||
| 167D* | Page 52, line 16, leave
out from ("defence") to end of line 31 and insert ("for
that person to show--
|
||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 168 | Page 52, line 23, leave out ("the") and insert ("a") | ||
| BY THE EARL OF NORTHESK |
|||
| 168A | Page 52, line 26, at
end insert-- ("( ) In proceedings against any person for an offence under this section it shall be a defence for that person if the key has been destroyed by either human intervention or the automatic operation of software as part of a routine practice designed to protect the confidentiality of a business or its customers or counterparties.") |
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND |
|||
| 168B | Page 52, line 27, leave
out subsection (4) and insert-- ("(4) If the person adduces sufficient evidence to raise the issue as to whether it was reasonably practical for him to make disclosure of a key to protected information before the time by which he was required to do so in accordance with a section 46 notice the court or jury shall assume that the defence under subsection (3) is satisfied unless the prosecution proves beyond reasonable doubt that it is not.") |
||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE VISCOUNT ASTOR |
|||
| 168C | Page 52, line 34, leave out ("two") and insert ("ten") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 169 | Page 52, line 37, at
end insert-- ("( ) A court shall be entitled to draw any reasonable inference as to the nature of the protected information where a person guilty of an offence under this section is charged with any other offence.") |
||
| After Clause 49 |
|||
| BY THE BARONESS THORNTON |
|||
| 169A | Insert the following new Clause-- | ||
| (" .--(1) Where
a person is found guilty of an offence under section 49 this fact shall be
recorded on a register which the Secretary of State shall establish and
maintain in such manner as will afford convenient and rapid access to
anyone with a material interest in knowing whether or not a person has
been found guilty of an offence under section 49. (2) Pursuant to subsection (1) the Secretary of State shall lay before Parliament within three months of Royal Assent to this Act his directions as to how the register shall be established and maintained, and the circumstances in which, and by whom, it may be accessed and at what cost.") |
Register of offenders. | ||
| Clause 50 |
|||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE LORD McNALLY |
|||
| 169B | Page 52, line 38, after ("46") insert ("or (Permission for notice requiring key disclosure)") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 170 | Page 52, leave out
lines 42 and 43 and insert-- ("during the period within which the notice is in effect, to keep secret from any specified person, or class of persons, the giving of the notice, its contents and the things done in pursuance of it, and to inform any other person who is made aware of any of those things of the requirements of the said provision") |
||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 171 | Page 52, line 46, leave out paragraphs (a) and (b) and insert ("the consent of an ordinary Surveillance Commissioner has been obtained") | ||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 171A* | Page 53, line 6, leave out ("the key to which it relates is a key to protected information which") and insert ("the protected information to which it relates") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 172 | Page 53, line 15, at end insert (", or class of persons") | ||
| 173 | Page 53, line 16, leave out ("makes a disclosure to any other person of") and insert ("explicitly discloses to any other person") | ||
| 174 | Page 53, line 17, after ("secret") insert ("from that person") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 175 | Page 53, line 26, leave out ("software") and insert ("systems") | ||
| 176 | Page 53, line 32, leave out subsection (6) | ||
| 176ZA | Page 53, line 46, at
end insert-- ("( ) Nothing in this section shall prevent any person described in subsection (1)(a) or (b) taking such action as may be necessary to preserve the confidentiality of any communication (other than that concerning the protected information described in section 46(1)) unless such action is expressly forbidden in the section 46 notice.") |
||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 176A | Page 54, line 19, leave out from first ("the") to ("or") in line 20 and insert ("Intelligence Services Commissioner") | ||
| 177 | Page 54, line 20, at end insert ("or Assistant Surveillance Commissioner") | ||
| Clause 51 |
|||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE VISCOUNT ASTOR THE VISCOUNT BRIDGEMAN |
|||
| 178 | Page 54, line 32, at
end insert--
|
||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 179 | Page 54, line 37, at
end insert--
|
||
| After Clause 51 |
|||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 179A | Insert the following new Clause-- | ||
| (" . Any person disclosing a key in an unauthorised manner shall be liable for any damage so caused.") | Liability for unauthorised disclosure of key. | ||
| Clause 52 |
|||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 180 | Page 55, line 31, at end insert (", and does not affect the intelligibility or accessibility of that communication or data") | ||
| 181 | Page 55, line 37, leave out ("or both") and insert ("the establishment of the authority conveyed by it, or any combination of these things") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 182 | Page 55, line 38, leave out from ("means") to end of line 40 and insert ("anything (including any key, code, password, algorithm or other data) the use of which, with or without any other thing") | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 183 | Page 55, line 41, leave
out paragraphs (a) and (b) and insert--
|
||
| BY THE LORD BASSAM OF BRIGHTON |
|||
| 183A* | Page 56, line 12, leave out subsection (2) | ||
| 183B* | Page 56, line 16, leave out ("protected information") and insert ("information (including a key to protected information)") | ||
| 183C* | Page 56, line 19, after
("concerned;") insert--
|
||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 184 | Page 56, line 24, leave out subsection (4) | ||
| 185 | Page 56, line 34, leave out sub-paragraph (iii) | ||
| BY THE LORD McNALLY THE BARONESS HARRIS OF RICHMOND THE LORD PHILLIPS OF SUDBURY |
|||
| 186 | Page 56, line 38, at
end insert ("; and
|
||
| Clause 53 |
|||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 187 | Page 57, line 3, leave out paragraph (a) | ||
| BY THE LORD COPE OF BERKELEY THE VISCOUNT ASTOR THE VISCOUNT BRIDGEMAN |
|||
| 188 | Page 57, line 5, at end insert ("and 14 and 15") | ||
| BY THE LORD LUCAS |
|||
| 189 | Page 57, line 8, leave out ("Chapter II of") | ||
| BY THE LORD | |||